How often you should change your oil is a matter of some debate. Many old school purists argue that you should change it every 3,000 miles. Others say that modern oils and engines can go much further.
So who’s right? And does it make a difference? A Honda master tech has a convenient visual that some are saying makes the case for changing your oil more often: engines that had oil changes every 10,000 and 5,000 miles.
In a Facebook Reel that’s generated over 526,000 views as of this writing, Matt (@hondamastertech) does a side-by-side comparison of the engines.
What’s the Difference Between the Engines?
In the Facebook Reel, the Honda tech showcases the stark contrast of engines with different oil change intervals.
The first engine to be revealed had 5,000-mile oil-change intervals. This engine looked to be in great shape. The second engine shown had oil changes every 10K miles. This engine was discolored looks much more worn down.
Looking at the two engines, based on appearance, the one with oil changes every 5K miles appears to be in better shape than the one with 10K-mile oil change intervals.
While Matt doesn’t speak in the video, the caption “change your oil” makes it clear which engine the Honda tech prefers.
Peace of Mind is Worth the Cost of Extra Oil Changes
This side-by-side comparison sparked debate among viewers over which oil change interval is best.
While most viewers suggested getting an oil change around 5K miles, some insisted it should be every 3K miles.
“I change mine every 5k miles with synthetic oil that meets the vehicle’s manufacturer requirements,” one Facebook commenter said.
“Any oil I do 3,000 miles intervals,” one shared.
“If you’re using synthetic then you’re wasting your money. But it’s your money so,” another replied.
“I change it every 5k. She doesn’t drink a drop of oil,” a Honda Civic driver added.
“I change mine every 3,500-4,000. Can’t wait to open the valve cover 20 years from now,” another boasted.
While some viewers believe you can wait thousands more miles between oil changes.
“Oil change done recommended by my shop every 7,500 miles,” one said.
“Oil changes every 9-12k miles for my 2024 RAV4 hybrid. 184k miles so far no problems,” another shared.
While other viewers chimed in, noting that the cost to replace the engine will be way more than the cost of frequent oil changes.
“I tell people this all the time they think I’m trying to scam them. ‘Well you’re really gonna hate when I quote you that $8,000 motor,’” said one.
“I don’t mind spending extra 40 dollars to have peace of mind and you can’t beat that smooth feeling on your engine,” another added.
Should You Change Your Oil More Often?
While there is a wide variety of beliefs about the best oil change frequency, one thing everyone can agree on is that regular oil changes are standard car maintenance. Being on top of oil changes will improve engine performance, extend engine longevity, and improve gas mileage, Progressive reports.
Both Kelley Blue Book and AAA report that oil changes should be performed between 5,000 and 7,500 miles for most engines.
In the past, the popular rule of thumb was that oil changes should occur every 3,000 miles or every three months. However, this is now outdated, Consumer Reports shares. With advancements in oil blends and engines, getting an oil change every 3,000 miles is unnecessary.
According to Valvoline, synthetic oils can last up to 10,000 miles.
It’s best to consult the owner’s manual, as the interval will depend on the vehicle you drive.
What Oil Should I Use?
When it comes to oil changes, it’s vital to use the right oil for your vehicle. Having clean oil keeps the engine running smoothly by properly lubricating its components.
According to Valvoline, there are four types of oil to know about:
Synthetic Oil: Oil that was created in laboratory conditions that utilizes multiple different chemical compounds that reduce friction. This oil lasts longer than conventional, but it is pricier.
Conventional Oil: Mostly used with older vehicles with a crude oil base. It is often the cheapest but needs to be replaced more often.
Synthetic Blend: A Combination of both conventional and synthetic oil. This blend has the advantages of the synthetic oil with lower prices, but it doesn’t last as long.
High Mileage Oil: Made particularly for vehicles with over 75,000 miles. This oil tries to address issues that arise in older engines in a preventive manner. This oil reduces oil consumption.
The cost of an oil change will vary depending on what oil your car needs. This price range can range from $30 to $100, depending on the type of oil, AutoZone reports.
Conventional oil will be on the lower end, at $30 to $50, while synthetic oil costs $60 to $100.
Knowing which oil to use is just as important as the oil change intervals to prolong the engine’s lifespan. Using the wrong oil reduces engine life and decreases fuel efficiency. You should review your owner’s manual for details on the right oil for your car.
Motor1 has contacted Matt via email and Facebook direct message. The story will be updated if he replies.